Robert Downey Jr. vs Ryan Gosling: Who Deserves the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor 2024?

Published 12/03/2023, 3:22 AM EST

via Imago

The silver screen sizzled with excitement when Barbie and Oppenheimer clashed on the same premiere day, marking a cinephile’s dream come true. But the drama did not end there; it extended to the awards season battleground. Oppenheimer, eyeing an Oscar with Cillian Murphy vying for Best Actor, clashed swords with Barbie for the Best Supporting Actor award. Robert Downey Jr., in a departure from his usual roles, delivered a career-defining performance as Lewis Strauss in Christopher Nolan’s classic, showcasing his dramatic prowess.

Meanwhile, Ryan Gosling lit up the screen as Ken in Greta Gerwig’s vibrant existential comedy, both actors emerging as top contenders for the coveted trophy. Now, it is time to dissect and discern who stands the best chance of clinching the prestigious award. The stage is set, and the battle for the Best Supporting Actor Oscar is on.

Ken vs. Lewis Strauss: The depths of character transformation

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

When cinematic maestros like Nolan and Gerwig pour their souls into masterpieces like Oppenheimer and Barbie, the acclaim naturally follows. Amidst the accolades, the ultimate goal for many is to snag the revered Oscars trophy. Oppenheimer contends across several categories, facing stiff competition, particularly in the Supporting Actor category with Gosling’s portrayal of Ken. Downey brought an explosive intensity that left an indelible mark. Despite his Marvel universe fame, Downey’s talent shone, showcasing him as one of the finest actors out there.

Playing Lewis Strauss, Downey Jr. seized the screen with his acting prowess, leaving a significant impression. Witnessing him deliver such a robust big-screen performance is an opportunity not to be missed. Gosling was an absolute marvel as Ken. He effortlessly embodied the role, exuding sheer joy and delight in his portrayal. Every quip and facial expression was timed to perfection.

DIVE DEEPER

Cillian Murphy Calls Robert Downey Jr. “unpredictably brilliant” as He Shares His Experience With Him on ‘Oppenheimer’ Set

over 1 year ago

The magnetic pull of Ryan Gosling’s Ken-ergy

In the Barbie world, Gosling’s performance was not just acting—it was an enchanting display of dedication. Critics showered praise on Gosling’s role as Ken, celebrating his ability to blend humor with genuine depth. He infused Ken with a captivating mix of comedy and authenticity, turning what could have been a simple character into a profound reflection on societal norms. What seemed like a shallow or potentially villainous character on the surface transformed into a witty yet thought-provoking commentary?

via Imago

Gosling’s history with the Oscars, having earned nominations for La La Land and Half Nelson, elevated the buzz around his exceptional portrayal. His metamorphosis into Ken was nothing short of magical, shifting effortlessly from a charming partner to a lovably clueless character. This journey not only stole the spotlight among the Barbie ensemble but also showcased Gosling’s musical roots, crafting a performance that was a delightful symphony for audiences and critics alike.

Robert Downey Jr.’s riveting performance- A path to Oscar glory

Robert Downey Jr.’s turn in Oppenheimer was a total game-changer from his usual suave roles. In Christopher Nolan’s biopic, Downey Jr. played Lewis Strauss, an unexpected departure from his Tony Stark charisma. Above all, the movie jumped between bomb-making and Strauss’s bid for cabinet approval, painting a unique dual picture that cleverly contrasted Cillian Murphy’s Oppenheimer. Among a stellar cast, Downey’s performance stood out like a shining star, hailed in reviews.

via Imago

His complete transformation into a different character revealed his sheer acting. Moreover, a win for Downey would not just honor his career; it would celebrate his unmatched skill in a role that showcased his versatility like never before. Additionally, Downey Jr.’s got the upper hand over Gosling in the fame department. He is a Hollywood legend on the verge of veteran status. He ruled the roost as Iron Man in the MCU for over 15 years, rubbing shoulders with half of Tinseltown along the way. Come award time, this might just be the perfect moment for that recognition.

DIVE DEEPER

Zendaya’s ‘Dune: Part Two’ Delay Assures an Oscar Win for Cillian Murphy’s ‘Oppenheimer’?

about 1 year ago

Crafting the gold standard for supporting actors

Currently, they both snag spots in the list of top five predictions for Best Supporting Actor, joining the ranks with Colman Domingo (The Color Purple), John Magaro (Past Lives), and Robert De Niro (Killers of the Flower Moon). Now, what makes them stand out as potential nominees? Well, they each bring that touch of villainy, and the Academy adores that. More so, just look at past winners and nominees like Sam Rockwell, Tom Hardy, J.K. Simmons, Michael Fassbender, Barkhad Abdi, and Christoph Waltz.

And here is the twist – they are both semi-transformative. Downey Jr. underwent a stunning ageing transformation with makeup and hairstyling, while Gosling sported bleach blonde hair and jaw-dropping costumes, fully embracing his character’s essence. Transformative roles are a surefire way to catch the Academy’s eye, just like previous nominees Sacha Baron Cohen, Sam Rockwell, and winner Jared Leto. Not to mention, these two are no strangers to the spotlight. Many top-notch actors have shone in the supporting category, and they’re no exception.

Leading the pack: Who takes the lead in the Oscar race?

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

In the showdown between Gosling and Downey Jr., Gosling could take the lead. The early reviews already shouted for Gosling. Downey Jr.’s role in Oppenheimer scored rave reviews, but with the film sharing the limelight with Murphy’s lead and Nolan’s direction, Downey Jr. might have been outshone or got a bit lost in the mix. Conversely, Gosling truly shone in Barbie and stood solo as the prime contender for the supporting actor category, stealing the spotlight and etching an indelible impression from the flick.

What sets Gosling’s performance apart is its unexpected and invigorating essence, a departure from the ordinary. While Downey Jr.’s act is compelling, it could seem familiar compared to similar portrayals. Yet, despite Gosling’s standout approach, Downey Jr.’s praised performance and overdue acknowledgement might just turn the tables in his favor and shape the story.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

DIVE DEEPER

THESE Ryan Gosling Trademark Screams Deserve Oscars for Being ‘Pitch Perfect’

almost 2 years ago

Who do you think would win the race for the best supporting actor? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Riva Khan

680 articles

Riva Khan is an entertainment reporter at NetflixJunkie. Given her love for the language and writing, she has honed her narrative skills from a young age. She loves her latest tea in Hollywood and keeps an eye on the news.

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK