Amidst much anticipation, The Witcher’s season 3 arrived with a mix of excitement and controversy. Navigating through alterations from the books, the unexpected exit of Henry Cavill, and the uncertain fate of Rience, the season kept fans on their toes. Despite a slight decline in viewership, the show retained its position among Netflix’s top-performing series. However, it was Cavill’s replacement with Liam Hemsworth that sparked a firestorm of fury among devoted fans of The Witcher and the actor alike.

The news came as a crushing blow, leaving the future of the beloved series hanging in the balance. The reason remains shrouded in uncertainty and ignites passionate debate. Amidst this fervor, the writer has a cryptic response.

Henry Cavill’s exit rumors from The Witcher attract a cryptic response

The departure Cavill from the show struck a deep chord with fans. This led to a significant decline in viewership for season 3. The exact reasons behind his exit, however, remain shrouded in mystery. Speculations circulated, suggesting that the show’s deviation from the books might have clashed with Cavill’s desires for his character. In response, the series’ writer took to Twitter to defend the decision, hinting that there is more to the story than meets the eye.

“For those who claim that we don’t read/respect the books – the writers’ draft of The Witcher 306 ABSOLUTELY began with Dykstra holding Geralt at knife point,” tweeted one of the writers.

In the midst of the intense backlash directed at the writers for veering away from the books, their recent response served as an intriguing hint for the fans. The screenwriter, in addressing the recasting issue, offered a cryptic response, suggesting that something significant unfolded behind the scenes, writing, “what really went down behind the scenes“. As Cavill remains silent on the matter, the exact details of what transpired behind closed doors remain a mystery. It has left fans to wonder about the untold story.

In the midst of widespread speculations surrounding Cavill’s departure, The Witcher’s showrunner has intriguing insights to offer on the recasting decision.

Lauren Hissrich reveals why Geralt was re-cast

“There’s just too many stories left to tell,” says Hissrich. In a bold revelation, the showrunner admits that they could have chosen to end the show with Geralt’s departure. However, they recognize the vast array of untold stories that lie ahead, beckoning to be unraveled on-screen. The decision to retain Geralt’s character becomes paramount, as it upholds the sanctity of the original books and ensures the series remains faithful to its source material.

Addressing the hot topic of recasting, the showrunner acknowledges Cavill’s commendable portrayal of Geralt, delivering the character with unparalleled intensity. However, she emphasizes that Geralt’s essence extends beyond the confines of the books. He is an entity of its own within the show’s universe. Now, with Liam Hemsworth stepping into the role, there is no denying the daunting task of filling bigger shoes. Yet, she remains optimistic, asserting that with perfect execution, the show’s sanctity can be preserved.

What do you think could be the meaning behind the writer’s cryptic tweet? Let us know in the comments below.