Stranger Things has never shied away from testing its characters’ limits, blending supernatural horrors with the raw struggles of adolescence. Season 4 amplified this formula, thrusting Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown) into a new world of high school bullies and identity crises. As fans dissected every frame, one question dominated theories: Would El’s growing powers and pent-up rage push her toward a darker path? The answer arrived in a scene that divided creators and viewers alike.

The pivotal moment unfolded at Rink-O-Mania, a neon-lit roller rink in Lenora Hills. Eleven, was still adjusting to life after Hawkins, faced relentless bullying from classmate Angela. During a visit from Mike, Angela orchestrated a public humiliation, labeling El a “snitch” over the loudspeaker. A milkshake thrown at Eleven triggered her explosive retaliation: she struck Angela with a roller skate. Showrunners framed this as a glimpse into El’s moral ambiguity, but fans celebrated it as a triumph.

The scene’s tension hinged on subtle details, Eleven’s trembling hands, Angela’s smug smirk, and the crowd’s deafening jeers. It mirrored real-world struggles with bullying, making the payoff visceral. Yet, creators emphasized that the act was not just self-defense but a crack in El’s heroic facade. Could this moment foreshadow a darker arc in Season 5, which will be releasing soon. As for Viewers, they latched onto the raw satisfaction of seeing El fight back.

'Stranger Things' 5 Update: Eleven, Will and a Key Third Character to Take Centre Stage in the Final Chapter

Fans were not buying the dark side narrative; they were too busy cheering.

The show framed Eleven’s action as morally complex but, fans flooded Reddit with unabashed praise. Comments like “And Angela absolutely deserved it” and “The way I cheered when she hit her” dominated discussions. Many applauded Millie Bobby Brown’s raw performance, arguing that El’s strike was justified. “Yes, El’s response was to choose violence—and honestly? It was deserved,” wrote one user. Others rewatched the scene repeatedly, admitting, “every time I watch this, I feel a jolt of excitement.” Even hopes for Angela’s downfall persisted, with fans quipping, “I hope she begs for El’s help in the next season.”

Stranger Things may have aimed to hint at Eleven’s darker potential, but fans transformed the moment into a cathartic victory. This disconnect highlighted the deep connection audiences have with El’s journey, as they root for her resilience rather than her flaws. As Season 5 approaches, it becomes evident that whether she emerges as a hero or an antihero, Eleven’s choices will continue to captivate and keep the fandom on edge, sparking discussions and debates about her evolving character.

Millie Bobby Brown Opens Up on the “emotional” Toll of Wrapping Up ‘Stranger Things’, Calls It an Unrelatable Experience

Was Eleven’s strike a step too far or a long-overdue stand? Drop your take in the comments below!