Everwood had it all: small towns with big emotions, close family bonds, and heartbreaking tragedies. Whether it was Dr. Brown’s second chance at life, Ephram’s heart-wrenching choices, or the tangled relationships of Everwood’s residents, they all made it more than just a show; it felt like home. But who says the story has to stop there? With these 13 shows like Everwood, there are plenty more where that came from!

From the emotional bonds of Virgin River to the snappy mother-daughter duo of Gilmore Girls, these shows know how to tug at your heart. Some lean into family dramas, others explore love and loss, but all promise unforgettable stories. Which one will be the next favorite? Time to count down the best picks!

13. When Hope Calls

In the quaint town of Brookfield, sisters Lillian and Grace open their hearts and an orphanage, bringing hope to children in need. When Hope Calls spins tales of love, community, and resilience, much like Everwood. The sisters' journey to create a family echoes the warmth and dilemmas of small-town life. Fans of Everwood will find comfort in the show's heartfelt storytelling and the strong bonds that hold the community together.

‘Medusa’ on Netflix: Cast, Plot, Trailer, and All You Need to Know About the Upcoming Drama Series

12. Party of Five

After a tragic accident claims their parents, the Salinger siblings - Bailey, Charlie, Julia, Claudia, and baby Owen find their way through life's ups and downs together. Party of Five is the kind of wholesome drama that needs to be on your watch list, full of heartfelt moments, raw emotions, and a deep family bond that makes every episode a one-of-a-kind experience! The series does not shy away and paints the struggles and wins of young adults stepping into roles beyond their years, echoing the emotional depth found in Everwood.   

11. Longmire

Set against the rugged landscapes of Wyoming, Longmire follows Sheriff Walt Longmire, a tough-but-fair lawman who always gets the job done—no matter how messy it gets. Full of mystery, drama, and good old-fashioned Western grit, the show keeps things intense while going deep into the small-town struggles. It may be darker than Everwood, but it has that same feeling of community, internal struggles, and messy relationships. Plus, with turns coming at you from every direction, it is the type of show that hooks you in and refuses to let go!

10. Brothers & Sisters

If Everwood had an older sibling, it would be Brothers & Sisters. The show is about the Walker family, a close-knit but dysfunctional group of people fighting with love, loss, and life-changing secrets. Like Everwood, it is about messy family relationships, strong parents, and kids struggling to find their own way. With its sentimental moments and tearjerkers, Brothers & Sisters will give you that same emotional rollercoaster you got from the Browns’ journey!  

9. Parenthood

If Everwood brought you to tears, Parenthood will hit you right in the feels—in the best way possible. The Braverman family experience is a lovely, crazy blend of love, laughter, and life's greatest challenges. Sibling rivalry? Check. Parenting dilemmas? Countless Emotional moments? More than you are ready for! Much like Everwood, it sweeps you up in a world in which family is not perfect, but the love is genuine. With its small-town appeal and extremely heartfelt storytelling, this one will have you in stitches, tears, and reaching for your loved ones by the end of each episode!

8. Northern Rescue 

A widowed father packs up his kids and moves to a small town, hoping for a fresh start—but the small-town life comes with big emotions. Northern Rescue brings all the heartfelt drama Everwood fans love, following a family trying to heal, rebuild, and move through life’s twists. William Baldwin’s character, much like Andy Brown, juggles single parenthood while wrestling with his own grief. It is touching, emotional, and full of those raw, real moments that make family dramas so addictive!

7. Good Witch

What if Everwood had a little bit of magical mystery to it? Meet Good Witch, a series that brings small-town charm, deep relationships, and life lessons, just like Everwood, but with an extra sprinkle of mystery and magic. Cassie Nightingale, like Andy Brown, becomes a pillar of her town, offering wisdom and warmth to all those around her. If you loved the close-knit community of Everwood, you will adore the comforting vibes of Middleton.  

6. Hart of Dixie

A big-city doctor moving to a small town and struggling to fit in? That is Everwood all over again! Hart of Dixie follows Zoe Hart as she trades New York for Bluebell, Alabama, and finds herself at odds with the quirky townspeople—just like Andy Brown in Everwood. It has got that sweet small-town charm, warm relationships, and a dash of romance, making it the perfect lighthearted show to fill that Everwood-shaped hole in your heart! 

5. Gilmore Girls

- Cast: Lauren Graham, Alexis Bledel, Scott Patterson  

- Release Date: 2000  

- Seasons: 7  

Both Gilmore Girls and Everwood dish out small-town charm, warm conversations, and parent-child relationships that keep you hooked. But where Everwood gave you Andy and Ephram’s emotional rollercoaster, Gilmore Girls brings the snappy, coffee-fueled bond of Lorelai and Rory—equal parts witty, loving, and occasionally tiring. Stars Hollow, like Everwood, is the kind of town where everyone knows your name (and your business), making every episode feel like a cozy catch-up with old friends!

4. Providence 

Dr. Sydney Hansen returns to her hometown to reconnect with family and find herself again—ring a bell? Providence and Everwood both share the same theme of returning home to heal, both emotionally and physically. Just like Andy, Sydney must mend fences while getting used to a slower lifestyle. It is warm, sentimental, and full of good life lessons that will remind you why you loved Everwood so much!

3. Dawson’s Creek

Everwood had some of the best teen drama moments, and if you are craving more, Dawson’s Creek has got you covered! Both shows revolve around teenagers dealing with love, identity, and family struggles in small, picturesque towns. Just like Ephram Brown, Dawson Leery is a dreamer with big aspirations, going through complicated relationships and personal growth. With heart-wrenching storytelling and coming-of-age themes, Dawson's Creek delivers all the emotions you loved in Everwood!  

2. Virgin River

A woman seeking a second chance finds herself in a small town—but rather than peace and quiet, she finds romance, friendships, and a few surprises along the way. Virgin River brings all the emotional depth, stunning scenery, and heartfelt connections that Everwood fans adore. The slow-burning storytelling and warm relationships make every episode feel like a comforting escape. And just like in Everwood, the town itself feels like a character—full of charm, drama, and people who just cannot seem to mind their own business!

1. Chesapeake Shores

If Everwood’s family drama and second chances were what you loved most, then Chesapeake Shores is a must-watch! This show follows the O’Brien family as they work through love, loss, and reconnecting after years of separation. It is full of emotional moments, stunning scenery, and complicated family dynamics that are just as rich and emotional as Everwood's. Plus, Treat Williams stars in both, so it is like coming back home in more ways than one!

With shows like Everwood, there is no shortage of heartfelt storytelling, small-town charm, and characters who feel like family. Maybe Good Witch’s small-town magic is calling. Or Providence’s mix of heart and healing is just what you need. And if Virgin River's romance and drama are not on the list yet, what are you waiting for?

Is the 2024 Series ‘American Nightmare’ on Netflix Based on Real Events? Should You Watch It?

Which of these shows captured that Everwood magic for you? Or is there another gem that deserves a spot on the list? Let us know in the comments below!