Something strange happens when a TV show mixes supernatural terrors with spine-tingling mysteries - that is exactly why Sleepy Hollow became a cult favorite. Fans searching for a TV show like Sleepy Hollow will love the mix of spooky folklore, detective work, and hidden ancient secrets that make these tales so addictive. A time-traveling Ichabod Crane, nightmarish Headless Horseman, and an existence ruled by dark forces— Sleepy Hollow delivered non-stop chills and suspense! 

Searching for more supernatural mysteries leads to worlds where fairy-tale figures roam among mortals, a devilish detective running a crime unit, and hunters battling creatures from the shadows. Every show on this list, from cursed towns to secret societies, promises some spooky edge-of-the-seat suspense. Let the supernatural marathon begin!

10. Mayfair Witches

What do you do when you find out you are the heir to a family of powerful witches? Ask Rowan Fielding, played by Alexandra Daddario, who suddenly discovers that her bloodline comes with magic, and a creepy presence that just will not leave her alone. Mayfair Witches is full of spooky family secrets, supernatural drama, and a growing war between good and evil. Sounds familiar? 

Just like Ichabod had to solve age-old secrets, Rowan must piece together a dangerous past while dealing with dark forces that refuse to stay buried. With two seasons, Mayfair Witches is available to stream on AMC+ and Amazon Prime Video. If Sleepy Hollow’s mix of folklore and modern-day sleuthing kept you hooked, this one has got that same spellbinding pull—with a heavy dose of that witchy drama! 

10 Best Thriller Movies on Netflix That Are Sure to Leave You Stunned

 9. Salem  

Forget what you learned in history class because Salem flips the script on the infamous witch trials. Mary Sibley, played by Janet Montgomery, is secretly pulling the strings behind the mayhem, and as hysteria grows, so do some very dark supernatural forces. As with Sleepy Hollow, Salem takes real-life history and twists it into something even more terrifying!  

With three seasons, Salem is streaming on Hulu and Prime Video. If you enjoyed the creepy, history-meets-horror atmosphere of Sleepy Hollow, Salem delivers the same mix of suspense, supernatural chaos, and characters trying to outsmart ancient evils.  

8. Constantine

In Constantine, Matt Ryan's John Constantine is like Ichabod Crane if he swapped historical knowledge for demon-slaying skills and a trench coat. He is a cynical, chain-smoking exorcist who fights to keep hellish beings from taking over the planet, while fighting his own dark past. Like Sleepy Hollow, this series is full of prophecies, biblical horror, and an unwilling hero who keeps getting dragged into supernatural struggles.  

Though Constantine only lasted one season, it remains a fan-favorite and is available on Prime Video and Apple TV. If you miss Ichabod’s quick wit and monster-of-the-week adventures, Constantine is here to fill that void with more demons!

7. Superstition

The Hastings family runs a funeral home, but their real job? Protecting their town from things in the night. Led by Isaac Hastings played by Mario Van Peebles, this family battles ancient evils, conspiracies, and mysterious creatures lurking in the shadows. Superstition is like the small-town version of Sleepy Hollow’s battle against the apocalypse!

With one season, Superstition is available to stream on Netflix. If you enjoyed Sleepy Hollow's family legacies, secret societies, and supernatural battles, this show will scratch that itch, while keeping you on edge!    

6. Evil

A psychologist, a priest-in-training, and a contractor walk into a room to investigate cases of possession by demons. Evil is as unpredictable as they come, are these strange occurrences supernatural or just twisted tricks of the mind? Just like Sleepy Hollow, Evil weaves together horror, mystery, and faith-driven battles against the unknown.  

Spanning across four seasons, Evil can be streamed on Netflix and Paramount+. If you enjoyed Sleepy Hollow’s eerie investigations and constant questioning of what is real, this show will have your head spinning and your heart racing!  

5. True Blood

In True Blood’s world, vampires are not hiding in the shadows but are drinking synthetic blood and trying to fit into human society. But things get dark fast, and waitress Sookie Stackhouse, played by Anna Paquin, gets caught up in a supernatural war. Similar to Sleepy Hollow, this series goes deep into myth, folklore, and creatures that refuse to play nice!

With a comfy binge of seven seasons, True Blood is available to stream on Hulu and Max. Now, if Sleepy Hollow's mix of historical legends and modern-day danger appealed to you, True Blood offers the same creepy thrill—just with a few extra vampires!  

4. Lucifer

Tom Ellis's Lucifer Morningstar has had enough of Hell and decides to spice things up by helping the LAPD solve crimes. Between celestial drama, biblical prophecies, and steamy romance, this show delivers humor, heart, and high-stakes supernatural chaos just like Sleepy Hollow. Plus, if you love epic showdowns, the best fights in Lucifer feature everything from angelic brawls to devilish smack downs that will have your adrenaline pumping. 

With a good runtime of six seasons, Lucifer is streaming on Netflix. So, if you were swooning over Ichabod’s charm, sarcastic humor, and supernatural detective work, Lucifer offers all that and more—except he is the actual Devil!    

 3. Once Upon a Time

Storybrooke is more than a tiny village, it is the home to fairy tale characters who have forgotten who they are. Emma Swan, played by Jennifer Morrison, finds herself pulled into a magical battle against evil curses, time-traveling plots, and mythical heroes with hidden agendas. Spanning seven seasons, Once Upon a Time is available on Disney+ and Hulu. 

If you were hooked by Sleepy Hollow’s reimagining of historical figures, this show follows that lead, takes classic stories and turns them into an addictive, magical mystery.    

2. Grimm

Detective Nick Burkhardt, played by David Giuntoli, believes he is just cracking ordinary crimes—until he discovers he is a Grimm, born to battle mythological monsters living among humans. Similar to Sleepy Hollow, this series brings folklore into the present-day world, balancing detective work with epic battles of good vs. evil. 

With six seasons, Grimm is streaming on Prime Video and Peacock. If you miss Sleepy Hollow’s dark fantasy, historical roots, and action-packed investigations, Grimm is the perfect replacement!  

 1. Supernatural

Sam and Dean Winchester, played by Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles, have been fighting demons, ghosts, and mythical creatures since day one. With family legacies, biblical prophecies, and apocalyptic dangers, Supernatural shares Sleepy Hollow’s mix of history, horror, and heroism. With 15 seasons, Supernatural is available to stream on Netflix, along with many other horror shows on the streaming giant. If you enjoyed Sleepy Hollow's monster-of-the-week episodes with grand mythology, this show will keep you binge-watching for weeks!  

Dark secrets, supernatural forces, and thrilling mysteries—each of these TV shows like Sleepy Hollow has something special to offer. Whether it is the demon-hunting adventures of Supernatural, the fairy-tale twists of Once Upon a Time, or the creepy cases in Grimm, these shows keep the chills coming, guaranteeing a binge-worthy experience! 

David Arquette’s Dewey Riley Back to Life? ‘Scream’ Brings Exciting News for Its 7th Movie

Which show from this list gave you the most chills? Or is there another supernatural mystery that needs to be included here? Let us know in the comments below!