Horror's hall of fame might welcome many ghosts, but Sarah Michelle Gellar's Helen Shivers remains stubbornly six feet under. As Hollywood's reboot machine cranks out another nostalgic slasher revival, fans dared to dream that the original scream queen might miraculously return from her bloody 1997 demise. Her character's beauty pageant breakdown and dramatic death scene carved Helen into cult status faster than any fisherman's hook, leaving devotees praying for resurrection magic when news of the sequel surfaced.

While fans clung to hope like teens to flashlights in a blackout, Sarah Michelle Gellar swung the final axe, ending every revival fantasy with wit sharper than any slasher’s blade.

Just like Buffy took down vampires with flawless precision, Sarah Michelle Gellar has now slayed any hopes of returning to I Know What You Did Last Summer. In a chat with Entertainment Weekly, director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson revealed her heroic attempt to resurrect Helen Shivers, only to be met with Gellar’s signature wit. “I was the most dead a person could be,” Gellar quipped, with Robinson adding that she also joked, “You can see my frozen body. I am dead. I am Sarah Dead Gellar.”

Horror movie logic often stretches believability thinner than a final girl’s odds of survival, but not even Jennifer Kaytin Robinson’s “relentless” creativity could undo Helen’s spectacularly visible demise. The director revealed that she pitched everything, from wild survival theories to death-faking plots, only to run headfirst into the immovable wall of continuity. Their friendship survived where Helen could not, though Sarah Michelle Gellar jokingly told PEOPLE she had given herself an "unofficial job title" on the production: continuity consultant, and the self-appointed guardian of the fictional grave she refuses to rise from.

Sarah Michelle Gellar Wishes Her ‘Do Revenge’ Director on Birthday With Photos That Includes ‘Stranger Things’ Actress Maya Hawke and Camilla Mendes

While Sarah Michelle Gellar guards the grave with icy resolve, the franchise has already exhumed other familiar faces, proving that in horror, some legacies refuse to stay buried.

While Sarah Michelle Gellar's ghostly presence remains strictly off-camera, the franchise has not abandoned all ties to its hook-wielding past. It was confirmed that Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. (Gellar's real-life husband) are both returning to their original roles, bridging generational slasher gaps. They will share the screen with fresh-faced potential victims, including Outer Banks star Madelyn Cline and Bodies Bodies Bodies actress Chase Sui Wonders, youth meets experience in this blood-spattered reunion tour.

Mark calendars with a crimson X for July 18, when this nostalgic nightmare returns with sharpened blades to theaters nationwide. Though Helen Shivers will not be miraculously thawing for another round of terror, her legacy haunts the production through Sarah Michelle Gellar's witty commentary and steadfast commitment to logical storytelling. Some characters, it seems, get to rest in peace, even when Hollywood's reboot machine works overtime to disturb the slumber of '90s horror classics.

2025's Ultimate Horror Movie List: 10 Flicks You Can’t Miss!

Would you still watch the 2025 reboot without Sarah Michelle Gellar? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.