5 Perfect True-Crime Romance Shows to Add to Your Perfectly Unique Valentine's Day Watch

Published 02/04/2025, 12:58 AM EST

Valentine’s Day is not just about roses and candlelit dinners. Sometimes, love is best served with a side of mystery and a few jaw-dropping twists. A woman swoons over a charming man until his secrets start unraveling. A couple’s love burns bright, but their choices pull them into dangerous territory. True-crime romance is wild, intense, and full of surprises with the kind of addictive drama that makes your heart race for all the right and wrong reasons.  

If you are planning the perfect ending to your Valentine's Day plans, here is something more thrilling than candlelit dinners - these shows are the ideal mix of passion and crime!

Desperately Seeking Soulmate: Escaping Twin Flames Universe

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

In the world of online communities, few have sparked as much intrigue and controversy as the Twin Flames Universe. Led by Jeff and Shaleia Divine, this group promises to take people to their perfect "twin flame" - a concept suggesting that each soul has a perfect match. However, the docuseries Desperately Seeking Soulmate: Escaping Twin Flames Universe reveals a thrillingly darker narrative.

The show follows the lives of current and former members who reveal how they were drawn into the Twin Flames Universe, lured by promises of love and spiritual fulfillment, only to find themselves caught up in a psychological manipulation, coercion, and even financial exploitation scenario. Some were even urged to cut ties with family and friends, while others were pressured to maintain relationships that were emotionally and psychologically devastating. 

A New Tone for ‘Black Panther’? Ryan Coogler Desires to Introduce Horror in the MCU; Internet Reacts

This docuseries streaming on Amazon Prime Video is based on candid interviews and investigative journalism that exposes the tactics of the Divines in holding control over their followers. It depicts the fine line between guidance and manipulation, giving the audience a sobering look at how vulnerable individuals can be preyed upon under the disguise of love, which makes it a one-of-a-kind thrilling watch that will give you the chills!

The Tinder Swindler

The Tinder Swindler is a gripping Netflix documentary that tells the story of Simon Leviev, a man who posed as a wealthy diamond heir to charm women worldwide. He showered them with lavish gifts and promises of a luxurious life, only to manipulate them into funding his extravagant lifestyle. The show does not shy away but goes deep into the psychological tactics he used, like love bombing, to gain trust and exploit his victims. 

The Tinder Swindler offers a perfect timeline of events, even showing the sad and deep emotional and financial impacts of the victims. The show has been loved for its compelling narrative and the alarming portrayal of a real-life con. So, if you are a fan of true-crime stories that bring in romance and have a darker side, The Tinder Swindler offers a chilling yet captivating watch, and it is available for streaming on Netflix, so catch it before it is gone.

Crazy Love

In Crazy Love, you meet attorney Burt Pugach and young Linda Riss from the busy 1950s New York City streets who had quite the whirlwind of a romantic story. Their love story took a dark turn when Linda discovered that Burt was still married. Heartbroken, she ended their relationship. You would think it ended here, but no, it simply gets chillingly worse going to extreme situations you probably cannot digest!

Linda ending the relationship fueled Burt's rage, which slowly turned into an obsessive vendetta. In a shocking act of vengeance, he masterminds an attack on Linda, leaving her permanently disfigured. To the surprise of everyone, in the most astonishing move here, they end up reuniting and even getting married years later, defying all expectations. Catch this exclusive new kind of crazy real-life tale of passion on Tubi now before it is gone!

Bad Surgeon: Love Under the Knife

There are few medical stories as chilling as that of Dr. Paolo Macchiarini. Once hailed as a pioneer for his groundbreaking stem cell-infused windpipe transplants, Macchiarini's reputation was built on promises of life-saving procedures. However, the reality was far more sinister, leaving his patients suffering to death.

Bad Surgeon: Love Under the Knife is a three-part Netflix docuseries, that probes deep into Macchiarini's rise and fall. It follows investigative journalist Benita Alexander, who gets herself romantically involved with this surgeon. Their whirlwind affair, filled with luxury and charm, soon unravels as Alexander discovers the horrors there about Macchiarini's medical practice and personal life. 

The series masterfully meshes true crime with romance and drama that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats with every passing minute. Now, if you are intrigued by this premise and love a good dark tale of deception, drama, and horror, Bad Surgeon: Love Under the Knife is an engrossing study that you must witness at least once!

Love Fraud

Richard Scott Smith was the perfect manipulator of online dating, spinning a web of deceit for over two decades. He preyed on women seeking love, using charm and false identities to con them out of hundreds of thousands of dollars. Many of his victims were women whom he married or promised to marry, leaving them financially and emotionally drained.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Love Fraud is a four-part documentary series where private investigator Carla Campbell teams up with Smith's victims to track him down across the country, uncovering the extent of Smith's scams and the profound impact on his victims' lives. The series ends with a powerful confrontation, giving you a satisfying ending that sides with the strength of those you refuse to be silenced. Simply scroll through this series available to stream on Paramount Plus with Showtime and you will find yourself compelled to continue watching further in no time!

Love is not always sweet, it can be thrilling, dangerous, and full of exciting twists. These true-crime romance shows prove that passion and crime make for an irresistible combination. Whether it is star-crossed lovers caught in a web of secrets or shocking betrayals that change everything, each of these stories keeps you on edge. To celebrate this Valentine's Day, skip the usual rom-coms and dive into love stories with a darker side.

‘Apex’ on Netflix: Cast, Plot, Trailer, Release Date and All We Know About the Upcoming Wild Thriller

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Which true-crime, romance show is your favorite? Drop your picks in the comments below!  

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Akshaya Deeksha

169 articles

Akshaya Deeksha is an Entertainment Writer at NetflixJunkie. With her passion to explore the evolving world of entertainment and her journalistic sense, she specializes in cinematic storytelling and Hollywood developments. Her expertise in lifestyle writing allows her to connect with readers through relatable content.

Edited By: Itti Mahajan

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK